The Demolition Man - A Belated Review

 (Blogger's Note: Yes, I have been a little lax in posting here but I've had three books due this fall. Two are now completed and the rough draft of the third is almost done.  In other words, I'll have more time to devote to this site... I have notes for two short stories in mind that are somewhat intriguing. I'll try to get those done soon. And, for those interested, two more of the Jefferson's War novels have been published.  The cover to the first it on the right... You can find them at Amazon a ebooks... Take a look.)

Just the other day I happened to see The Demolition Man, that Sylvester Stallone movie from the late 20^th century. While it is a fun film with some predictions that are frighteningly close to the mark in the world today (language monitored with fines levied for the use obscene words) there were others that were way off the mark. There was, for example, no huge earthquake in California in 2010 and there was no Nine Years War (I think that was what they said).

There were a couple of flaws that inspired me to comment on them. Things that the writers and the director should have thought of as they made the film. One of the minor points was Simon Phoenix, the really bad guy, was working some sort of computer station that had a keyboard but no letters on that keyboard. He was approached by a number of police officers who, if some in our world had their way, would be more social worker than law enforcement, he saw one of those officers standing near a wall. Phoenix attempted to activate the anti-graffiti electrodes. He was told that there was a human too close by but Phoenix was able to override that inhibition. The electrodes activated, killing the police officer.

Here’s the point. Why would Phoenix be able to override the safety command? There is no positive benefit for the ability to override that system. It was system was designed to prevent injury. Overriding it could, and in fact, did result in the death of the police officer.

But that’s not the problem that caught my attention. Simon Phoenix, and by extension, the hero, John Spartan, needed to find firearms. Of course, in the world of The Demolition Man, no one has firearms and everyone is somewhat docile. They don’t swear, they sing along with mini-tunes which we think of as advertising jingles, and they don’t seem to have a bad thought in their barbecued brains. Why, they don’t even swap bodily fluids in the course of what we think of as normal activities… You know, they don’t kiss and use a machine to engage in sexual intercourse (can you say Sleeper?).

Both Phoenix and Spartan realize that there will be guns in the museum (though in that world I’m not sure why they’d have a Hall of Violence). Here, on display are all sorts of weapons from hand guns to howitzers. There are “modern” weapons that include some sort of laser weapon that fires explosion bolts of light. There are machine guns and hand grenades and all sorts of ammunition for the various weapons. My question is “Why?”

I can think of no reason that a museum would have, on display, weapons that were still functional. For the rifles, they could have removed the bolts, or at the very least, the firing pins. Why wouldn’t the barrels of the weapons be spiked so that even if they could be fired, the projectile would not leave the weapon.

And all the displays of the ammunition should have been rendered inert. That means that you could have the bullets and the shotgun shells and the artillery shells but there would be no explosives in them.

In fact, you wouldn’t even need to display the real weapons. Mock ups and replicas could serve the purpose and even if someone stole one, it would be of no use to him. The look and feel of the weapons could seem to be real when they were just models to show what the things looked like.

Or, in other words, the weapons wouldn’t work.

To find weapons, Phoenix and Spartan, would have to find another source. There is one, of course. In the movie, there is an underground world. Those who don’t wish to have their lives regulated to the extent those living on the surface are. They have hamburgers, or rat burgers, they live in the squalor of that lower level, and they have all sorts of weapons.

This does lead to another problem and it is Taco Bell, the winner in the “franchise wars.” We’re told that all restaurants, in 2032 are Taco Bell, but Taco Bell is part of Yum Brands that include other restaurants such as KFC (formerly Kentucky Fried Chicken) among others. Yum! won the franchise wars so wouldn’t some of the restaurants be KFC or other franchises owed by Yum!

I will note here that, like all movies set in the future, they get so much wrong. I won’t go into all that but instead mention couple of things that seem to be coming. There were the self-driving cars and I think, but 2032 we might have those all over the roads.

They don’t like gasoline, though at one point in the film, it seems that gas makes up an important component of the plot. They’ve done away with toilet paper and replaced them with the three sea shells. I don’t see that happening, and just like John Spartan, I don’t know how they work.

Of course, we must remember that the movie was not made to please me, but to appeal to a wider audience. There are the required fight scenes and the big gunfights. There is some humor that those in the future wouldn’t understand but we do… I’m thinking of the mini-tunes.

I could nitpick the film from this point by why? I enjoyed it and I overlooked the big weapons grab in the museum. I stumbled at that point, but that doesn’t change my impression of the movie. It was a fun film with some nice little insights into the future and some frightening predictions that seem to be coming true… I think “cancel culture,” and the attempts to grab and maintain power by manipulation of the system. It seems to be warning us about those who see the world in one way and wish to impose that vision on the rest of us. You must do this or… well, you’ll find yourself in some sort of trouble because opposition, no matter how well intentioned must be eliminated.

But I digress into political commentary, which, by the way, is one of the aspects of good science fiction. Provide a look into the future, or an alternative future, that is predicated on where we are and where we might be going.

Anyway, if you have an hour or two, and haven’t seen it, The Demolition Man is a fine way to spend a little time. Turn off your brain to ignore the frightening implications of our future and watch Stallone and Wesley Snipes battle one another while the San Angeles police and others watch in horror.

Science Fiction and UFOs

 

Here’s something that I have said for years. When a technologically superior civilization encounters a technologically inferior civilization, that technologicalyl inferior civilization ceases to exist. We have seen numerous examples of this through the course of our history. We don’t have to look very far into the past to see it.

Sitting Bull, the Hunkpapa Lakota medicine man warned the Lakota to leave everything on the battlefield after the defeat of the five companies with George Custer. His point was that they, the Lakota, did not have the technology to reproduce those artifacts, whether they were guns, steel axes and knives, or even the cooking utensils. He knew that an iron pot was better for cooking than a clay pot and a steel ax was sharper than one created from stone. He knew that the Lakota would become dependent on those things and that would alter their society… probably not for the good.

It was in 1960, I believe, that the Brookings Institute published a document in which they made this observation. The superior technology would overwhelm the society without the technology and that would doom that technologically inferior society.

I mention all this now because I just reread a book that my mother bought for me when I was ten. It was a Fawcett Gold Medal science fiction novel entitled Four from Planet Five. It is about four children who arrive at an Antartic research station in what seems to be a spaceship. Clearly, anyone with a spaceship, back in the middle of the twentieth century anyway, had a superior technology.

Normally, this wouldn’t be of interest to anyone into UFOs, and one or two of the things in the book wouldn’t be of interest to those who read science fiction. However, there was something I found on page 59 that might be of interest to both groups.

To quote from the book:

And he had an immense, a fascinated yearning to work with the innumerable possibilities the technology of the children’s race suggested.

“I don’t like any of this,” he commented to Gail. “If they children’s people find out where they are I don’t see how we humans of Earth can survive the contact with so superior a culture. The American Indians collapsed from meeting a civilization not nearly so far ahead of them. The Polynesians died of mere contact with a whale-ship culture. But we’ve got to face something a lot more deadly.”

You can argue that these examples aren’t just of contact but of warfare. Yes, there was fighting between the expansion of the Europeans into the native territories, but it was the superiority of the technology that actually doomed the indigenous peoples. The rifle and pistol were superior to the bow and arrow but the Indians couldn’t make them. They had to rely on the technology of the Europeans and the Americans for those items.

And it wouldn’t have been just weapons. All sorts of items would be introduced and even if the contact had been benign, the end result would have been pretty much the same. The technology would have won.

But the real point is that this concept, which I have quoted often in the past, was out there, in the world of science fiction before the academics had put it down on paper. Oh, there might by other examples of this in the anthropological history of the human race. I just found it interesting that the concept was part of a science fiction novel published in 1959 that has an impact on the world of the UFO.

Four From Planet Five - A Book Review

When I was a kid, only ten or eleven, I was interested in science fiction. While at the super market one day, on one of the racks of paperback books that held genre novels including westerns, mysteries and romances, I spotted Four From Planet Five. I asked if I could have it and my mother agreed. It was only 35 cents, which in those days was a nice bit of money for a book, but she agreed. I have long since decided that she agreed because she wanted to read it too.

Now, for decades, I have hauled that book around. It has followed me as I moved from one state to another, which is to say that I still have it. True, the clue is given away because, as you can see the cover isn’t pristine, but I do have it.

I mention all this because I just reread it after all these years. I remembered nothing about it, except that the kids were supposed to be telepathic. Of course, you could learn that by reading the cover blubs, so that was no big deal.

Clearly, the book, by Murray Leinster, was written quickly. It is fairly short and tells us the story rather than show us much of it. The science is late in the 1950s. The children, that is, the four from planet five, identify Jupiter, not only by its size but by the twelve moons that orbit it. We’re much smarter today because we know the number is 79 plus a couple of moonlet, but I didn’t really care about that…

The children are horrified by the craters on our moon, suggesting that the destruction there was caused by the destruction of the postulated planet in orbit between Mars and Jupiter. The children can’t speak English, of course, and none of the adults can speak their language so there is a communication problem.

Their ship arrives with a sudden burst of static, so powerful, that it is heard on radios and televisions all around the world. I’m not sure about the science here but it sounded something like an electromagnetic pulse which would be more or less line of sight. In other words, the radios and televisions on the other side of the world might not have been affected but that’s just a minor problem.

The main male character, Soames, a scientist, laments that he will never earn enough to support the journalist, Gail Haynes, but that doesn’t stop him from wishing. Of course, that is all turned around when the ship bursts into the airspace over the Antarctic where they both happen to be working. Soames, who is also the helicopter pilot, flies her out to look for the object they are sure is down somewhere near their outpost. It gives him an excuse to hang around with her.

It is clear to me that Leinster knew nothing about helicopter operations, given the way he described the flight. That’s really no big deal, but since I am a helicopter pilot, I spotted this right away and, of course felt the urge to mention it.

Wilson "Bob" Tucker with his
ever present bottle of Beam's.

As an irrelevant aside, Bob Cornett and I wrote a science fiction novel, Seeds of War. We kept getting it rejected. Well, not always. One editor was going to buy it, but he got fired and the book was returned. He tried to buy it at his new publisher, but got fired again. Bob and I knew Wilson Tucker who had published some 25 very good but underappreciated science fiction novels so we asked him to take a look at it. When we visited him at his home, one of the first things he said, “Which one of you is the helicopter pilot?”

I hadn’t thought there was anything particularly insightful about the way I had described the helicopter operations, but Bob (Tucker, aka Wilson and not Bob Cornett) knew that one of us was a helicopter pilot… but I digress.

We learn that the cause of the big static burst was an alien ship that crashed. Flying over it, they saw four children, hardly dressed for the cold, outside the ship. They looked human, but, of course, they couldn’t be.

Here, we see the first of the scenes in which we are told more than we are shown. No big deal, but it was something that I noticed throughout the book.

Sure, the story was okay, but I thought some of the developments in the book were not properly set up. The romance between Soames and Haynes developed a little too quicky. People do fall in love at first sight, but this just seemed rushed to me. Almost within hours, they’re talking about marriage.

And we have the military man… well, woman, Captain Moggs… really, we couldn’t give her a name that was somewhat more attractive. Moggs, of course, isn’t all that bright but is following her orders, such as they are. She is not a nice person, but given the name, what would you expect?

Within a few pages, we have the world on the brink of atomic war because the Americans have access to the children, with the technology that seems to be far superior to anything on Earth. True, Fran, one of the children, blew up the remains of the ship to keep it out of the hand of we savages, but that didn’t stop the rest of the world from believing that Americans had access to all that technology.

Soames makes a few deductions based on very thin information that turn out to be correct. Again, I didn’t think that sufficient evidence was supplied for him to leap to the conclusions that he did because the theory is so radical that I’m not sure it would cross the mind of a scientist. On the other hand, I suspect a science fiction writer would leap to it because it is much more fun than interstellar travel.

There is a sort of nice twist at the end of the book, but I won’t go into that because I see that you can buy the book on Amazon if you’re so inclined. Spoilers, you know.

I will point out that the book felt rushed, meaning that I think Leinster wrote it for the bucks in a hurry. I think it was one of the old-time mystery writers who said that he once locked himself in a hotel room for a weekend to knock out a book. Needed the cash.

It’s a nice story though, but it just isn’t as developed as it could have been. I believe that given that it was Fawcett Gold Medal Book, and since it was a paperback to being with, back in the days when most people looked down their noses at paperback books and paperback writers, I don’t think anyone took the care with it that they would have taken with a hardback.

 That doesn’t mean it’s a bad book. I had no trouble getting through it. I saw the flaws and just ignored them. It was a fun story with a hint of romance and a world that was about to go up in flames but then the world is always about to go up in flames. It’s just not a Nebula or Hugo worthy book, but then it wasn’t meant to be. It was designed to appeal the science fiction audience, and that it does. It was designed, I believe, for the quick buck. It’s not a masterpiece but it is a serviceable story. Let’s say three stars, maybe three and a half out of five.

The Tomorrow War - A Review

 I took time out Saturrday to watch The Tomorrow War, which is a movie presented by Amazon Prime, starring Chris Pratt. The basic idea is that there has been some sort of alien invasion in the future that was working and the human race had been reduced to about a half million people. Somehow the future humans had opened a portal into the past and were now recruiting people from the past to fight in the future in an attempt to save humanity. Well, that is a bit confusing but that’s what the movie is about.

MAJOR SPOILERS BELOW:

Chris Pratt is a former special operations soldier, Don Forester because, apparently, the military has no regular soldiers anymore. He has a nice little family, but is recruited for future duty. We learn that the survival rate for these recruits is about thirty percent. We learn that the tour is one week in the future and when those 168 hours are up, the soldier returns to his “home” time automatically, no matter where he is or what shape he is in.

And here’s where I become annoyed. They recruit the people, from all over the planet, including, it would seem, those who had no military service, who have never handled any sort of a weapon, and who are not necessarily in peak physical condition. They’re just civilians who have been living their lives, aware of this war in the future but not overly concerned about it because it’s, well, in the future and they’ll never live to see that future. They have no special skills, no special knowledge that would help defeat the enemy, but are sent off to fight that enemy anyway.

They are given automatic weapons, but no real instruction on the care of those weapons. They wouldn’t know how to safely clear a jam, they have no fire discipline, and have no idea about target acquisition. In the real world, handing an automatic weapon to an untrained soldier would result in many, many friendly casualties. Never mind that, just throw them into the fight in the future and hope for the best. I will note here that fire discipline isn’t a concern because like all Hollywood weapons, the shooter has an infinite supply of ammunition.

During the first fight, as they’re blasting away at the creatures running at them, shooting off bits and pieces of the alien body with little effect, a veteran tells them that only hitting the soft underbelly is fatal. Wouldn’t you think that someone would have mentioned this important bit of intelligence before sending them into the fight. Not to mention giving them weapons that would be effective against the aliens. Wasn’t in one of the old Doctor Who episodes when the general of Unit wished they would meet an alien presence that wasn’t immune to bullets?

Don finally meets his daughter, Muri, in the future who is now a graduate of MIT and a colonel, in the Army, I think. She was annoyed with him for what he did to the family some years after he had left to fight in the war, which tells us at that point he survived the 168 hours he’s in the future. Of course, we already knew that given what he was told during his induction that he would die in seven years, which was why he could be recruited. So much for suspense.

There is a special mission to capture the brain bug, whoops, I mean the queen that is capable of creating thousands of beasts and that is an even more aggressive than the male versions. They helicopter over to the underground lair of the queen. Now, down below, we find soldiers who have, somehow, managed to get ropes on the queen and are attempting to drag it out where they can stuff it in a cage.

I’m thinking, ropes?

Really?

You don’t have a better plan… not that one was needed because they eventually succeed but only after they are kicked around in a way that would have killed most people.

The whole point is that they have developed a toxin that is affective against the males, but not so much the females. They need a female creature to find a formula that works… which, of course they do just before Don slingshots back to his own time.

Rather than killing the queen after developing the toxin, they keep it alive. It seems to be in some form of telepathic communication with hoards of the males. Of course, there is a major assault in which the humans are being overrun. Don can’t get Muri to the lab where they could manufacture the formula. Instead, she is killed just before he returns to his own time. There is a truly moving moment as they talk, heart to heart, because she is dying, but who cares? We understand time travel.

Oh, I don’t mean that we don’t care about the character, I’m saying that he is about to return to his time where his daughter will be alive and he can warn her about all this. No one ever thinks about those sorts of things. If he KNOWS when and where she dies, he can prevent it.

Anyway, he falls back into his own time with a vial of the toxin and then, someone figures out that all they have to do is find the point where the aliens first came to Earth. (Okay, it’s his wife, Emmy, but that’s not important now.) They can prevent the war. The clue is on a tooth or claw or something from one of the aliens and frankly, I don’t care what it was. It contained a bit of volcanic ash that identifies the crater from which it was ejected. The ash and the tooth. Some high school kid has the information they need about the volcano because why would you consult a volcanologist when you can talk to a high school kid about it. Anyway, the volcano is in Russia and it’s on to Russia because the movie isn’t long enough yet.

With the solution to the war at hand, with the ability to save, literally, billions of lives, the Earth governments aren’t interested in the plan. You have a guy, actually, a bunch of them, who have returned from the future, they know what it will take to keep the war from happening, but no one will listen to them. They are forced to take on the mission by themselves, flying in a C-130, into Russia, avoiding the radar and other sensors available to the Russians and ignoring the fact the C-130 doesn’t have the range to get there without refueling. They do arrive, however. They find the alien ship…

And now we know why the alien creatures don’t seem bright enough to cross the street let alone interstellar space have space travel. They were brought along to clear the Earth-based life from the planet so that these alien sentient beings can colonize… do a detect a subtle message here?

At any rate, they find the ship, they enter, and then let the queen escape. They didn’t want to destroy the ship. Think of the technological advances that could be made. But, then, there are so many of these creatures on it, they have no choice. The secret of interstellar flight is lost again, just as it was in The Thing from Another World. To quote the journalist in that move, “What a bunch of butterfingers.”

Of course, they have to chase down the queen in a fight that is ridiculous to watch. Here is this beast with huge teeth and claws and strength that is far superior to those fighting it. The bullets of their high-powered rifles are ineffective and I’m thinking, why didn’t they bring something along that would put that creature down for good. I’m thinking a grenade launcher or a fifty cal or something with a little bit of real power.

And that is the point. I have lost my sense of disbelief. Rather than being swept up in the story, I keep seeing the flaws in it. I don’t grant the writer and the director the privilege of creating a world that I will accept for the story. There are just too many gaps in the plot. Too many missed opportunities. And no reason, once they located the queen in the future world, they didn’t just nuke it. They look for a toxin to kill it, but I’m thinking if you know where it is, the nuke will take care of it because it is clear that these aliens aren’t wizards. They are, basically, animals and you would think that someone in that future war would have figured that out. And yes, there is more than one queen (which is the term I use but they don’t) but they found one, why not the others?

But here’s where we are. Don, his father, and some other guy, have killed the queen in their time and destroyed the ship, which means they won’t escape into our world, so there is no war. It ends at that point and Don’s daughter doesn’t die in the future as she did earlier in the movie.

I won’t go into the other problems with all this. Okay, just one more. Don knows that he’s going to be killed in a traffic accident in seven years. Since they’ve already made one change in time, can’t he make another and avoid the traffic accident? Just wondering.

So now that I have picked this apart, let me say this. I did enjoy the movie and some of that joy was picking it apart. I didn’t mind the virtual signaling that went on because it was more subtle than it is in some other movies (really, Anne Boleyn as a black woman, BBC?). The special effects were good, but I just wish someone had invented a weapon that would have allowed our soldiers to put down the aliens with a single shot rather than having to shoot them to pieces (which, eventually worked so that the movie wasn’t even faithful to its own devices).

If you have something over two hours to waste and want to see a mindless time travel/alien invasion film, well, this is some fun. Just don’t think about it, and you’ll be fine. At least you don’t have to pay for it on Amazon Prime, if you’re a member

Ornithoptera Lunaris

(Author’s Note: Back in the mid-1970s, my friend, Robert Charles Cornett (often called RC Squared for the obvious reason) and I decided we wanted to be science fiction writers. Oh, it was a thought I’d had for a long time and one that Bob had as well. We talked about it, and we wrote a number of science fiction short stories, which for some reason, were never selected for publication. Eventually, we did sell a number of science fiction novels including Seeds of War, and Remember the Alamo, both of which became limited series. We also put together a collection of short stories. The following is one of those.

Please remember that these stories were written in the mid-1970s. I point this out because cigarettes have a role in his story and it is not one that is easily removed. The structure of the story and one of the characterizations make it impossible to remove the references without destroying one of the characters. I elected to keep it in and point out that I don’t advocate using tobacco products.

I’ll also note that this story was written before there were home computers. The original manuscript was created on a manual typewriter and if you want to have some fun, try doing that. The keys require real pressure, you can’t go back to fix a misspelled word, and in fact, you can’t have the manuscript spell checked. I have added a couple of updated references however. Rather than reading a book its physical form, one of the characters is using a tablet. There are references to the Internet, added in the world today. We didn’t make these predictions back in the 1970s.

Anyway, the point here is that some of the references are dated and I’ve left almost everything intact which captures, I suppose, the flavor of the times. There will be an additional note at the end of this which is important. I can’t mention it here because, well, spoilers.)

 

Ornithoptera Lunaris

I

Bea Riley yawned, stretched her legs, and lit up another cigarette. Lambert, she noticed, had finished his book on plasma physics and was now reading an advanced calculus text. Not studying it, reading it, much as someone else might have read a bit of light fiction before going to sleep. In a moment, her presence intruded and he glanced at her over the top of his tablet. Another man might have asked her for a cigarette. Another man who had known her in college as Lambert had, would have asked her to share a cup of coffee and later a pass at her. Lambert did neither.

Lambert eyed her briefly. At 28, she was slender, athletic, and beautiful. She had long red hair and pale blue eyes that were as thin as cellophane. The line of her face was so fine it hurt him to look at her and his eyes dropped back to the tablet.

Lambert hated her cigarette smoking. He hated everyone’s smoking and couldn’t believe that the regulations allowed it but only because she claimed a tribal exemption. He wasn’t sure what tribe, or why the exemption would allow smoking, but the bureaucrats bought the excuse.

He couldn’t believe that in the enclosed environment anyone would be selfish enough to smoke. The habit disgusted him. It was a vile smelling, filthy habit that tasked the air scrubbers. People who smoked the filtered brands were bad enough, but Riley insisted on the damned Pall Malls that left little shards of tobacco in the smoker’s mouth.

Well, if she wanted the damn things bad enough to use up five percent of her personal effects allotment to bring four cartons and two fifths of scotch up to Tycho Crater, she could smoke them. Lambert just wished she’s smoke them in her own room instead of in the lounge where he was assaulted by the odor.

Riley’s chair creaked noisily as she got up. The smell of the tobacco became stronger and Lambert felt the hairs rise on the nape of his neck. She was coming closer and he wanted to run. Irrational, irrational, he thought, but he still wanted to run. Of all the women he had ever known, Lambert considered Riley to be the most desirable, and the most frightening. He was afraid of women, but Riley terrified him. When she spoke, he could tell from her voice that she was standing next to him.

“It’s beautiful. No matter how many times I see it, it’s always more beautiful than the last.”

“What is?” Lambert did not look up. He did, however, stop reading. The interruption had broken his train of thought and he found, to his great consternation, that he could not remember which integral he had been approximating in his head.

“Earthrise. Isn’t it fascinating how it hangs there, just over the rim of the crater? Like some giant, blue, half marble, striped in white.”

Lambert twisted around so he could see through the triple-layered, Plexiglass window. It was the only window in the station.

“Such poetic words. You’re a hopeless romantic, Riley. I must confess though, it does have a certain aesthetically pleasing quality.” Lambert was a scientist to the core. He had absolutely no sense of what constituted art, only numbers and formulae.

“The trouble with you, Chris, is that you have no soul.”

“Soul? Oh, you mean religion. Of course not. There’s no such thing as God. I don’t believe in mythology. Man evolved biologically, from the lower organisms.”

“Why?”

“Why what?”

“Why did man evolve? What was his reason for doing so?”

“Survival.”

“That’s not what I meant. Don’t you see, there has to be some purposive reason for man’s existence. Something must give reason to life.”

“I see no reason why there need to be any purpose behind chance biological occurrence.”

“Oh Christ, Chris. You’re the one who’s hopeless, not me.”

Lambert was spared the agony of further obviously futile discourse by Schattschneider’s entry.”

“I hope I’m not interrupting anything.”

“No, no. Dr. Riley and I were just discussing trivia. I believe Bea refers to it as religion. What’s up, Karl?”

“Well, I know you’re both on stand-down, but I’d like to ask you to go outside and have a look at the prime focus for me. There’s some kind of trouble with the reception and Edwards thinks it’s external. I wouldn’t ask you, but there’s no one else I can send. Tish Kirchoff and Spel Balfour are both on sleep cycle and Jirasek’s ill. He caught a head cold of some kind fooling around with the air conditioning unit. I’d go myself, but you know what the regs say: ‘Whenever external repairs are to be effected, a team consisting of two members must be sent out in order that one may assist the other, and, in the event of an emergency, a third member must remain suited up in the rescue lock to assist in the recovery if necessary.’ Well, that leaves me for lock duty. I can’t send Edwards or Garrick because they’re on duty and if I pulled them off, I wouldn’t be left with anyone to handle the data from the 500-meter interferometers or monitor the incoming signals from the Saturn probe on the 25-meter dish.”

“I’m game, Karl. Haven’t been outside for more than a week. Ready, Bea?”

Riley looked longingly in the cigarette in her hand. It was only a third gone. Eighteen more months to go at Tycho Base and she had only two and a half cartons left. She sighed and carefully stubbed it out, and zipped the remaining two-thirds of it into the sleeve pocket of her coverall.

“There’s something that I haven’t told you two,” said Schattschneider.

“What’s that?”

“The core elevator isn’t working. The main circuit panel is shorted out.” Immingham is working on it, but she figures it’ll take at least a day and a half to rewire. You’ll have to take the ladder up to number seven lock and walk it from there.”

Damn, thought Lambert. It was a 500-meter ladder climb to lock seven, then a five- kilometer hike along the trail to the summit and another 500-meter ladder climb to the prime focus.

“You know I wouldn’t ask if we could afford to postpone it until the elevator is fixed, but we’re right in the middle of the Coal Sack scan. We can’t afford the down-time.”

II

Tycho Crater has a radius of 40 kilometers with a rugged peak rising in the middle. At an expense of some thirteen billion dollars, the floor of the crafter had been bulldozed and smoothed into a parabolic basin and lined with high-gain radio cable. The prime focus sat atop the peak on a titanium steel tower. By varying the displacement of the focus along a track running the length of the 160-meter boom atop the tower the antenna could be ‘aimed’ throughout a traverse near thirty degrees. The whole project, electronic hardware and software, life-support system for the station crew, engineering and landscaping and the station itself, had cost the investing nations 125 billion dollars. It was the most powerful radio telescope in the solar system.

Lambert checked the chronometer on the wrist of his suit. The converter in the backpack would provide eight hours of breathable air. Estimating an hour each way for the hike and thirty minutes going and coming to climb the tower with the tools and equipment, that left four hours to find and correct the trouble and an hour’s emergency reserve. Lambert didn’t think there would be any problems.

He was wrong.

III

The trail hadn’t been used in nearly ten years, not since the core elevator had been completed, but despite the extremes of heat and cold, erosion is a slow process on the moon and the trail had remained virtually unaffected. It was pitted in places from the impact of small meteorites, but it had been originally designed for heavy construction vehicles and in most places was nearly a dozen meters wide. As Lambert covered the ground in three-meter bounds, using the loping gait most suitable for travel on the moon, he watched the little bits of gray dust arch out ahead in ballistic trajectories in front of his boots before plummeting back down. The cleat marks from the tractors used in the antenna construction hadn’t been seriously disturbed in the fifteen years’ time. They probably wouldn’t be in 1500 years either. As best he could remember, only about half a dozen others had hiked the trail since the antenna construction had been completed. After the development of the sub-micro circuit, maintenance had dropped to nearly nothing.

They were making good time and Lambert estimated they were only about half a kilometer from the summit when the first sign of trouble appeared; a large rock slide blocking the trail.

“Repair party to Tycho Base.”

“Tycho Base. Go.”

“We seem to be having a bit of a problem here. There is a large pile of rubble blocking the trail. I think we can navigate it, but it’s going to slow us down some.”

“Chris. This is Karl. What are you talking about?”

“There’s a large jumble of rock blocking the trail. Didn’t the seismographs pick up any tremors?”

“Negative. I’ll run a computer search, but nothing recent shows. Can you give me any more information?”

“We’ll take a closer look and let you know. As far as I can tell, the map coordinates ought to be about Blue Alpha 37. When we get to the base of the slide I’ll turn on my emergency beacon and you can get a transponder lock on the location.”

Fifteen puzzling minutes later Lambert called Tycho Base again.

“Karl, you’re not going to believe this, but it isn’t a rock fall. I’ve checked the inner wall face carefully and there isn’t any evidence of a fault. No sign that it was a slide at all.”

“Well, what is it then? Somebody didn’t just push the stuff up there. Is it meteor rubble?”

“I don’t think so. It’s all in great bid chunks and the composition doesn’t seem right. The stuff looks like it’s just plain moon rock to me. I’m afraid it looks exactly like somebody pushed it up here.”

“Karl. This is Bea. There’s something else. I just checked my dosimeter. It’s in the red zone. Chris’ is too. I ran a Geiger count, but it turned up negative.”

“All right. We can’t afford to take chances. Come on in and we’ll check everything out.”

IV

Schattschneider, Lambert, Riley, and Devi Razin were sitting at the table in the main lounge. Schattschneider was fiddling with his tablet and Lambert and Razin were sipping coffee. Riley got up from the table and walked to the window. She dug pack of Pall Malls from her left sleeve pocket, started to shake one out and then remembered the remains of the earlier one.

“Let’s not fog up the room with smoke now,” said Schattschneider.

She shoved remains back into the pocket and turned toward the table.

“You’re sure it’s not serious then, Dev?”

When the Indian doctor spoke, her English was slow and precise, like everything else about her, unhurried and exact.

“It should not be. You will probably have a headache and a little nausea in two days’ time, but you were not exposed for long. I do not believe the level was high, but we should know more when Evelyn gets here.”

As if on cue, the lounge door slid open and Immingham walked in.

“I’m inclined to disagree. Chris and Bea came out of decontamination nearly clean, but it’s going to take a while with the suits and tools. I’m afraid they were plenty hot. Hot and dirty as it turns out. I found residue on Bea’s book. Analysis suggests it’s what’s left of contaminated liquid sodium.”

Schattschneider put down his tablet and leaned forward.

“Reactor coolant?”

“That’s my opinion, Karl. It’s what I’ll put in my official report.”

Lambert lifted his cup, then slowly set it down.

“Look, it can’t be. We don’t dump waste anywhere near there. No one does.”

“Chris, I’m telling you it’s reactor coolant. From all indications, probably some type of fast-breeder. I found traces of zirconium containing twenty-seven percent uranium 235. There’s nothing else it could be.

Schattschneider said, “All right then. If Eve says it’s reactor coolant, then it’s reactor coolant. The question is, how did it get there?”

“Eve, what about the Geiger counter?”

“It seems to be in working order, Bea. I don’t like inventing theories, but I’d say it just sort of overloaded. My guess is that the impulses were impinging on the electron multiplier tube just too fast for the scaling unit to count. It wasn’t calibrated for as high a level as the stuff I found on your boot. A similar thing happened back in the 1950’s when they first discovered the van Allen belts.”

“Well, I suppose the first move is to contact all the other bases, see if any of them are dumping the stuff, though I can’t believe anyone would be that stupid.” Schattschneider left for the communications room.

Razin left for the infirmary to check on Jirasek and run some more lab tests. Immingham got herself a cup of coffee and walked back to the table. She sniffed the coffee, tasted it carefully, then set it down.

“I hate to bring this up, but sooner or later, we’re going to have to face it. Somebody is going to have to go out to that rock slide or whatever it is you two found, and measure the radiation level. That, and try to figure out what caused the slide, plus get through and fix the antenna.”

“Easy enough said, but can we do it? I mean, well, if the radiation level is really that high, won’t it be dangerous?”

“We’ll have to talk to Tish, she’s the physics expert, I’m only an electrical engineer with a physics background, but I think so. Whoever goes out could wear white coveralls inside the suit and a sun shield on the outside. I might be able to rig up some additional shielding, and I could recalibrate the Geiger counters to register higher levels, that way whoever goes could avoid the major hot spots.”

V

Two hours later they were all seated in the lounge again.

“Well, I checked with the other installations,” said Schattschneider. “They all wanted to know what we were drinking over here. None of them have any idea how reactor waste could have been dumped on the upper trail. Everyone dumps it in the Hadley Rill.”

“Who said it was reactor waste?” grumbled Balfour.

“I did.” Immingham gulped her coffee and made a face.

“And I concur.”

“Don’t be an ass, Karl. How could it get there?”

“That’s what we’re here to discuss.”

“I don’t really see how we can discuss anything until we have more data. Like I said to Chris and Bea earlier, someone is going to have to go back out there and take some readings.”

“All right. I suppose the antenna repairs will have to wait until we figure this mess out.”

“Okay, then. I’ll get down to the repair shop and see about rigging up that extra shielding. Tish can help.”

“Right. Now the question is, who goes?”

“Don’t look at me,” said Lambert. “I already gave at the office. So did Bea.”

“I don’t think they should go either.” Razin looked at Schattschneider. “They’ve already been exposed. I wouldn’t want them getting recontaminated.”

“I agree. Spel, you get suited up. Chris and Bea can relieve Garrick and Edwards and one of them can go with you. The other can stand by in the lock.”

“Gee, thanks.”

VI

Balfour and Garrick cautiously approached the slide. The Geiger counters began to climb rapidly as they neared.

“I guess we better try to find a way around this mess, Dave. Why don’t you work your way around to the left and I’ll try the right?”

“Check. Just make sure you don’t fall off the cliff.”

“No sweat.”

Garrick searched for several minutes and finally found a spot where the readings fell within safe tolerances. He found a few toe and hand holds and pulled himself up. Over the lip of the rocks he could see the antenna, or at least what was left of it. The titanium and steel tower looked like a plastic food container that had been left out in the sun too long.

“Well, shit. Spel, you there?” There was no answer. “Spel, this is Dave. You there, damn it?”

“Dave, this is Bud. What’s going on?”

“I lost Spel. Can’t reach him on the radio. He’s probably being blocked off by the rocks. I found a way over the slide. Not a good one, but a way. You’re not going to believe this, but the damned antenna is melted.”

“Say again all after damned.”

“I said the antenna is melted. Looks like a big pile of rubber. We’re not going to fix it with anything we’ve got at Tycho. I really doubt that it can be fixed.”

“Shit. Schattschneider isn’t going to like this one bit.”

“He isn’t going to like it? What about the taxpayers?”

“I guess you better find Spel and get back in here. Then we’ll decide what to do.”

Garrick searched for thirty minutes. There was no sign of Balfour. Finally, he worked his way toward the cliff, following Balfour’s footprints. They ended at the edge.”

“Oh my God… Bud. Bud, somebody answer quick.

“Go, Dave.”

“I… I… can’t find Spel. It looks like, well, it looks like he might have fallen off the cliff.”

“Damn. I’ll be right out.”

Edwards and Garrick searched for five hours. They crawled along the cliff and around the slide until they came to an impasse. They crawled over the slide and hiked for as far as the antenna. They searched both sides of the trail back to the station.

“Search party to Tycho Base.”

“Tycho Base. Go.”

“I’m sorry, Karl. We’ve checked and rechecked. There just isn’t any sign of him. If we don’t come in pretty quick we’re going to run out of air ourselves.”

“All right.” Come on in. We’ll put together another party to check the base of the cliff for the remains.”

VII

Lambert found Edwards in the biology lab. He was working with some white rats in a glove box. Zoology was not Lambert’s field, though he was always interested in any scientific endeavor, Lambert was, however, mildly surprised to find Edwards in the lab. Jirasek was in charge of life sciences, Edwards was an astrophysicist specializing in radio astronomy like Lambert.

“What are you up to, Bud, messing around down here in Ian’s private bailiwick?”

“Promised I’d feed the animals for him while he’s sick. Can’t just let all this expensive U.N. software starve. Ian told me it cost 125,000 dollars to send these two rats up here. The Council on Space Exploration’s appropriations committee would have a fit if we let them go hungry. Besides, the lab animals have become sort of a hobby with me. When I took my undergraduate work back at the University of Iowa, I had a double major, mathematics and zoology. I wound up taking my masters in physics and then moving into astronomy because they were starting to plan out the construction here and suddenly astrophysics looked to be a rosier pasture. I guess I had the astronaut bug pretty bad even then. You’d have thought I’d have gone into aerospace engineering and tried for a slot on the shuttle pilot list, but I don’t know, I guess I didn’t really feel I had a chance. Radio astronomy seemed like the closet I’d ever get to the stars.”

“Close as any of us will ever get, I venture to say. The problems with interstellar flight are too vast even for the science to handle.”

“I don’t know about that. I remember when I was very young, my grandfather once told me that when he was a little boy nobody believed that man would ever travel faster than the speed of sound. Too much friction, they said. If we can come as far as we have in three generations, well, who knows?”

“What on Earth, er, ah, what is that thing?” Lambert was indicating a large, foldout cork board along one wall.

“That,” smiled Edwards, “is the thing that keeps me from going crackers up here. My butterfly collection. I keep it here in the lab and I add to it from time to time. Finest butterfly collection on the whole moon, I dare say. In fact, it’s the only one.”

“Last time I checked, the lunar surface was not exactly considered prime habitat for Lepidoptera.  How do you add to it?”

“Over here. Butterflies. They’re part of Ian’s experiments. Turns out he has an interest in entomology too, so whenever one dies off, we mount it on the board, after we run all the tests, of course. Can’t mount them all, some have to be dissected, but we get a few that are submitted to non-destructive analysis. This one is our pride and joy. An Ornithoptera priamus. This one came from New Guinea, though you find them in the Moluccas, and in Australia. The exciting thing is that this one laid eggs and we got a few mutants. Ian thinks they function so well because they’re better adapted to the one-third gravity, usually mutants don’t survive because the delicate gene balance necessary to body function. Ian’s suggested we call them Ornithoptera lunaris, but I don’t think it’ll catch on.”

“Fascinating, but I really came down here to talk to you some more about the slide. When Bea and I were out there, I got the impression that, well, I suppose it sounds silly, but I had the feeling, just before we came back in, that somebody was watching us. I didn’t mention it to anyone because I didn’t want Razin declaring me unfit for duty. It’s been bugging me though, and I had to tell someone.”

Edwards stopped putting the water bottle on the hamster cage and looked at him steadily. “You know, Chris, when Dave and I were down at the prime focus mount, looking for Spel, I had a funny thought. I was looking at the tower, the way it was melted and all scrunched up, and I said to myself, ‘They swatted it, smashed it like a bug.’ I didn’t say, ‘The damned thing’s melted.’ I said, ‘They smashed it.’”

VIII

Schattschneider went down to the lounge. A bleary-eyed Immingham looked up at him from her cup of coffee.

“Any news?”

“None of it good. Dave and Bud are coming in. They didn’t find anything. He must have gone over the cliff. Do you feel up to checking the bottom?”

“I’m okay. Not nearly as tired as I look.”

“Okay.” Schattschneider walked over to the chair where Kirchoff had fallen asleep and put his hand gently on her shoulder.

“Tish, you awake?”

“What? Oh. What is it, Karl?”

“They didn’t find anything. Somebody is going to have to check the base of the cliff. You feel up to it?”

“Fine. I was just a little tired.”

“If you do find him, it may not be a pretty sight.”

“I can handle it.”

“All right, but take care of yourself. We’ve already lost one person. I don’t what to lose another. Especially you.”

“I promise I’ll be careful.”

Schattschneider kissed her and watched her walk out. Then he went back to the command center and sent Razin up to the rescue lock.

“We’ll take the train from lock five to the base of the cliff and start our search there.”

“Roger that.”

Kirchoff and Immingham sealed the lock, turned, and started along the lower trail. Unlike the upper trail, it had been built only for people and was quite narrow. It wound around the side of mountain and in places was blocked by large rocks which had to be climbed. It took longer to reach the base of the cliff than had been expected.

They found the suit easily because it was standing upright in the middle of the trail. Kirchoff gave a shout over the microphone and ran over to it. She reached out to touch the shoulder and it toppled slowly forward. Quickly, she turned it over and then recoiled in horror as she looked at the face plate.

The suit was empty.

“Karl? You there?”

“Yes. What is it?”

“We found… the suit.”

“I suppose… there… is no chance.”

“I really couldn’t say. I said we found the suit. He’s not in it.”

“You mean you found what’s left of the suit?”

“No. I mean we found the suit, damn it. Complete and unbroken. There’s no way that he could have gotten out of it.”

“Are you trying to tell me that you found an empty suit?”

“Not trying damn it. Am.”

“Well, where in the hell did he go then?

“God damn it. How should I know? I’m not clairvoyant. I’m telling you the damned suit’s intact, and I’m telling you the damned thing is empty.”

“I don’t think I like the sound of this.”

“How do you think we feel?”

“You’d better pick up the suit and bring it in.”

“Right. Eve, give me a… What the hell?”

“What’s going on out there?”

“Eve’s gone. She was right behind me. I was looking at the suit and when I turned around she was gone.”

Schattschneider shouted. “Tish, get back here right now. That’s an order. Forget about the suit. Forget about Eve. Forget about everything. Just get back in here!”

“I’m on my…”

Schattschneider’s ears were blasted by the scream over the speaker. He sat down heavily in the chair. “Tish! Tish! Speak to me, damn you. Speak to me.”

The radio was silent.

Schattschneider buried his face in his hands and wept. He was still crying when Lambert came into control room and helped him to his quarters.

IX

Fifteen minutes later they were all seated at the conference table in the lounge. Even Jirasek had come up from the infirmary. Edwards was seated in the director’s chair.

“Well, I suppose you all know the situation. We’ve lost three people… missing anyway. I suppose we have to presume that they are all dead.”

“I don’t think that we should presume anything.” It was Razin. “We don’t know what happened out there. They may still be alive. If they are, Eve and Tish still have enough air for four hours. I think we should try to find them.”

“I don’t know if that’s such a good idea or not. I don’t want to make the kind of decision that might get more people killed.”

“I didn’t know any one made you acting director.” They looked toward the door. Schattschneider was leaning against the frame.

“I didn’t mean anything by it, Karl. I was just following procedures. I, that is, we, didn’t know how long you would be, well, indisposed.”

“I’m fine now and I’m resuming command. We will, of course, mount a search party at once. This time, however, four of us will go. We’ll take back up radios and flares and we’ll leave someone outside the lock. If we get into trouble, we’ll fire a flare and he can report to whoever is left inside. That is, assuming radios are out. If we don’t come back, then that those who are left can get into contact with the main base at Copernicus and the higher-ups will have to figure out what to do about it. At any rate, if we don’t come back, I don’t think they should come looking for us.”

Garrick spoke first. “Karl, are you doing this based on your judgement as project director, or just because Tish is out there?”

“That will be enough of that, Dave. I’d do the same thing even it was you lost out there.”

“I really don’t know how to say this, but don’t you think we should take a weapon of some kind with us?” It was Edwards.

Garrick snorted. “What do you suggest we use for a weapon, your good looks? This is a scientific installation, not the Rocky Mountain Arsenal.”

“Dave’s right,” said Schattschneider. “I don’t know of anything here that could be used as a weapon and I don’t know what you think you’re going to do with it anyway. You act like there’s some kind of monster out there.”

“For all we know, there might be. Anyway, I just thought I’d feel better if we had some way to defend ourselves.”

“All right. We’ll split into two teams. Dave and Bud in one. Devi and me in the other. Jirasek can wait outside the lock as an observer. Lambert and Riley will stand by in the control room.”

“How come they get to stay behind?”

“You’re beginning to make yourself tiresome, Dave. Bea and Chris got a pretty good dose of radiation from their first trip out and Ian still has a head cold. This is going to be difficult enough without having along someone who might suddenly decide to get sick on us.”

“Got it all figured out, haven’t you? You’re going to go out there and find your mistress and you don’t give a damn how many of us get killed in the process.”

Schattschneider stared across the table at Garrick. For several seconds he said nothing, then there was a quiet snap and he laid the broken pencil on the table.

“All right, Garrick, I’m only going to tell you this once. Go out to the ready room and suit up. Then pick up a spare radio, a flare packet, and a coil of climbing rope, and get your ass up to lock number five. If you have trouble with that, you can file a formal complaint when we get back.”

Schattschneider rose and left. The others followed him. After a few minutes Garrick muttered something under his breath, rose, and walked out.

X

They formed up outside the lock and checked their equipment. Schattschneider noticed that Edwards was carrying a long pipe with a knife blade affixed to the end like a bayonet and a satchel of plastic explosive they used for excavations.

Schattschneider indicated the pipe. “Where’d you get that thing?”

“I used one of the legs from a camera tripod and a chisel bit from the soil sampler. Anyway, it makes me feel better, whether we need it or not.”

At the base of the cliff they split into two groups. “Try to keep the other group in sight and under no circumstances get separated from your partner. Loop a coil of rope around your left arm to keep together, but don’t tie yourselves up. At the first sign of trouble, send up one of the flares and get the hell out of here. Just don’t get excited and start reporting each other as three-eyed monsters.”

They found Balfour’s suit lying in the middle of the trail. It was still sealed and pressurized. For several minutes they tried reaching Kirchoff and Immingham on the radio, but there was no answer. It became inevitable that they lose sight of each other as they spread out in the search pattern.

Garrick and Edwards were working their way along the bottom of the crevice when they spotted the suits. They approached them cautiously. Both were empty, just as Balfour’s had been.

“Well, what the hell do we do now? Crawl back out of this hole and call the others or send up a flare and get the hell out of here?”

“How should I know? I guess we crawl up the slope and try to raise the others on the radio. I don’t know about you, but somehow, two empty space suits don’t look particularly menacing to me. Kind of spooky, yes, but not really threatening.”

“Okay. We’ll do it your way, but I suppose one of us ought to have a flare handy just in case.”

“Right. You do that. I’ll lead the way up the slope,” said Edwards.

Halfway up the slope, Edwards felt the line connection him to Garrick suddenly go slack. He turned around and saw Garrick’s suit tumbling slowly back down the slope as though it was empty. Then he saw it. Edwards did not wait to find out what “it” was. He threw the spear and ran up the slope, pulling a flare as he ran. As he neared the top another “it” appeared above him. Edwards pointed the flare and pulled the lanyard. “It” exploded in a ball of flame.

Edwards reached the top of the slope and was running in the direction he thought the others would be. As he ran, he popped two flares skyward and dug the plastic explosive out of his satchel. He primed the explosive and attached a ten-second timer.

Edwards ran down a gully. As he rounded a corner, he could see Schattschneider and Razin ahead of him. He yelled at them over the radio, but it didn’t seem to be working. Edwards stumbled into the suits, knocking them over.

They were empty.

XI

From the lock, Jirasek had seen the red streaks of light from the flares. He keyed the radio. “They’re in trouble.”

“Say again.”

“I said, ‘They’re in trouble.’ I can see the flares. Two of them. I’m going to help.”

“No. Don’t be a fool. You know what Karl said. Come back in immediately and seal the lock. Dog it shut.”

“Nothing doing. They need help. If they didn’t, they wouldn’t have fired those flares.”

“Ian, listen to me. Don’t go out there. Come on back in and we’ll call for help.”

It was too late.

Jirasek was gone.

XII

Jirasek broke out onto the plateau just in time to see the battle, such as it was. It wasn’t much of a fight. Three of the “its” were chasing Edwards across the plateau. Edwards turned just long enough to heave something. It landed in front of the three and detonated with a bright flash, stunning them. Two did not get up, but the third rose unsteadily and continued its pursuit. As Edward neared the edge of the plateau, the “it” reached out a long tentacle-like appendage and touched him on the shoulder. There was a flash of brilliant green light and Edwards stopped, frozen as if he were a statue.

For a full minute, Jirasek watched the proceedings in horror before he turned and ran. He ran back toward the base. He ran as hard and fast as he could. He ran until he felt as though his lungs were about to burst. He almost made it. He was within sight of the lock when they got him. He just had time to scream a warning to Lambert and Riley.

 Then there was nothing but silence.

XIII

Lambert did not see them grab Jirasek. He did hear the warning over the radio, but the transmission was so garbled that he could make no sense of it. Lambert’s first impulse had been to leave the station and help Jirasek. He was halfway out the lock before he realized what he was doing. He drew back suddenly and sealed the lock. Lambert was a scientist, with a scientist’s curiosity, but he was not a fool. He caught his breath and dogged the hatch. Then he started back down the ladder to the control room.

Riley almost jumped out of her coverall when Lambert entered. She dropped her pack of cigarettes, spilling most of them on the floor.

“Damn, Chris, you might have told me you were coming back down.”

“Sorry. I didn’t think. Did you hear Jirasek’s message?”

“Yes, but I couldn’t understand any of it. It sounded like he said he was collecting bottles.”

“That’s what I thought too. It doesn’t make much sense. Do you think, maybe, his mind snapped?”

“I don’t know what to think. I’m not a psychologist. I’m just an astronomer, and right now, I’m pretty a damned scared one, too.”

“Well, you can relax. I dogged the lock shut. We’re safe now from whatever it is.”

“I wonder, are we? You heard what Kirchoff said. Balfour’s suit was sealed, but he wasn’t in it. If whatever is out there could pull Balfour out of his suit without holing it, a steel door might not stop it either.”

“Walk through a steel door? Oh, come on, I don’t believe that. I didn’t figure you for one to believe in ghosts.”

“Who said it was a ghost? I’m just saying that a sealed moon suit didn’t stop whatever it is.”

“Maybe it’s the Russians. Maybe they took Balfour out of the suit and resealed and repressurized it to throw us off the track.”

“Kirchoff was a Russian. Whatever it is that’s out there got her too.”

“All right then, the Chinese. How do I know?”

“Maybe it isn’t Chinese either. Maybe it didn’t come from Earth.”

“There’s no sense making up an extraterrestrial explanation for something that can be explained in terrestrial terms.”

“May I remind you that we are not on terrestrial soil.”

“Oh, all right. Have it your own way. There’s a little green man out there who likes to reach through moon suits and make the occupants disappear with a wave of his magic wand.”

“It makes just as much sense as repressurizing an empty suit.”

“Horse shit”

“Are we going to stand here arguing or are we going to do something?”

“What would you have us do?”

“Not going outside, that’s for sure. We’d better try to raise Copernicus Base.”

They tried the radio. Then they tried the land line. They tried for an hour and a half. Nothing. Riley ran through a whole pack of cigarettes. Lambert ran through a complete set of replacement printed circuit cards for the radio. There was still no answer. Not from Copernicus, not from Alphonsus, not from Clavus. Nothing from Lomonosov Crater.

“I don’t understand it. All our communications can’t be out. Not at the same time. And I replaced every part in the damned radio.” Lambert sat in front of the radio panel staring at the flashing lights that told him nothing.

“I think we have to assume that whoever or whatever is out there, doesn’t want us talking to anyone else.”

“You realize what you’re suggesting? If whatever is out there is blocking our communications, it’s intelligent. I’m not sure I’m willing to believe that. If Balfour and all the rest had been killed by a rockslide or a quake, I could accept it. Even an energy plasma or radiation. If whatever got the others is intelligence, it must be human. It would mean all this is an organized attack on the base, and that could mean that we’re part of the opening act of World War Three… Well, you couldn’t even call it a world war anymore.”

“It might be somebody else, something else. It might not be human.”

“Bea, you’re talking about intelligence life from somewhere outside our solar system. Something with the technological capability to make interstellar flight a practical reality. The whole notion is preposterous.”

“So was building a permanent base on the moon thirty years ago. Now there’s half a dozen of them.”

“It’s not the same.”

“No, it’s not. But it doesn’t have to be. Less than a hundred years ago science was positive that man would never walk on the moon. Now we’ve mounted a dozen manned missions to Mars and over a hundred manned probes to the other planets, including those hidden in the Kuiper Belt. Who knows what a race that has been around for five hundred or a thousand years more than we have might have accomplished.”

“It won’t work, Bea. Einstein’s Theory of Relativity.”

“In the first place, we don’t know if Einstein is right. Nobody’s ever tried to go faster than the speed of light. Even if faster than light travel is normally impossible for natural phenomena, whoever we’re dealing with might have found a way to short-circuit the theory. They might not even have to travel at faster than light speeds. If Einstein’s theory is correct, time dilation should occur at relativistic speeds. If they weren’t concerned about the changes back home or had a very long-life span to begin with, speeds approaching that of light might be fast enough.”

“All right, Bea, I concede the possibility, though not the probability of the argument. All we’ve really established is that we don’t know what caused eight people to vanish. You take the alien theory. I think I prefer to stick with a more human enemy.”

“You are, then, at least willing to believe that we are dealing with an intelligence of some sort?”

“Not completely, but right now it’s the only thing that makes much sense. I’m willing to operate on that kind of assumption until I can find a more satisfactory explanation of why all our communications gear suddenly went out.”

“I guess then that the only real question is what do we do now.”

“We wait.”

“Just wait?”

“Just wait Sooner or later one of the other bases is bound to try to contact us, and when they find out they can’t reach us, they’ll send someone over to find out what went wrong.”

“How long do we wait?” Riley’s voice sounded flat.

“I don’t know. If there has been a war I’m pretty sure they’d try to read us fairly soon.”

“Maybe not. Not if they think we’re all dead over here. They might not to bother then.”

“Sooner or later somebody would try. We can last here for months without resupply. As long as we stay put we’ll be all right.”

“It seems to be that you’re overlooking a few points. If war had broken out, wouldn’t we have been notified, had some sort of indications at least, say from an increase in political tension on Earth if nothing else?”

“Not necessarily. Not if it had been a sneak attack. They might have sabotaged all communications, jammed the Internet and maybe even bombed the other bases.”

“Then why not bomb ours?”

“Maybe they wanted to take this place intact.”

“I don’t think so. The main antenna is melted, remember? Anyway, if they’d bombed the other bases, the seismographs would have picked up the tremors.”

“All right, so I don’t have all the answers. Maybe they just holed their habitats and let them suffocate. I still think our best move is to sit tight for a while. If nothing happens after a few days we can take the tractor out and try to reach the main base at Copernicus. That’s the biggest site. If it is war, and anyone survives, they ought to be there. Better be. Copernicus has the only landing facilities for the Earth Shuttle.”

“Once again, how long do we wait?”

“I guess about two weeks, unless whoever is out there tries to get in.”

“Why two weeks?”

“Ought to give the other bases time to reorganize, time to send someone to look for us. Besides, if Copernicus Base isn’t there now, it won’t be there in two weeks either, and if it isn’t there then, well, it won’t matter how long we wait.”

“I suppose we ought to make some sort of contingency plan. In case we have to leave here in a hurry.”

“Right. We should work on getting the tractor ready for an extended trip. Load in supplies, oxygen, so forth. Maybe rig up some additional shielding around it, just in case someone did detonate a bomb. Anyway, it’ll give us something to do. We ought to continue monitoring the radio, and keep an eye on the Internet, just in case. We’ll work out some sort of schedule, for monitoring, sleeping, working. That way we can have one of us in the comm center at all times. If they do restore communications, a message could come through at any time.”

“There’s something else we ought to do. The tapes will have all the radio conversations recorded, but I think we ought to make log entries for what we’re planning and doing. We ought to make a copy of the tapes and logs too. That way we can take one with us and leave one behind. If we don’t make it, maybe someone will find the set we leave here.”

Lambert started for the tractor locker and then remembered. “I guess we better try to fix the elevator first. It be one hell of a ladder climb to the crater floor.”

“Wouldn’t you know, the one piece of equipment in the whole place that doesn’t have printed circuits.”

XIV

It took almost two and half days to fix the elevator. During that time the radio and the Internet remained silent. Had either of them been an electrical engineer, it would not have taken so long, as it was, they had to go through the process of completely rewiring the main circuit panel with a technical display on one of the tablets.

On the morning of the third day, Riley was playing the communication tapes when Lambert entered the control room.

“I’ve been thinking,” he said. “If a state of war does exist, why hasn’t either side tried to force one of the air locks and take the base by now?”

“Maybe there aren’t any of them left. Maybe everybody killed everyone else off. That could explain why no one answers the radio.”

“Maybe, I don’t know. There are a lot of things that just don’t make sense. Everybody vanishing, but nobody trying to get in, the radiation counter and seismographs giving no indication of nuclear attack, the radio not working, the Internet still down, either for that matter, and somebody using the upper trail as a dumping site for reactor waste, plus the main antenna being melted. I don’t think all the other bases were wiped out any more. I think we’ve been isolated for some reason. I don’t know how or why.”

“Then you’re saying that whoever was out there is still there, but that they aren’t in any hurry about opening us up?”

“Oh, I don’t know what I’m saying. What have you got there?”

“The tape of the last communication with Jirasek. I was just about to play it back. Want to hear it?”

“Might as well. We’ve been so damned busy with the elevator that I’d forgotten about it.”

The quality of the recording was not good.

“…God… (static)… out. They’re… (Static)… Edwards… (static) …collection bottles… (static)… stay in… (static)…”

The recording ended in an unintelligible scream.

To hear any one scream like that was enough to give Lambert chills, but to hear a scream like that, not yell or swear or curse, but scream…

“Well, I guess that’s it,” Riley was saying. “I’m afraid about all I could get out of it was that he said ‘collection bottles’ and not that he was collecting bottles. To me, either statement makes an equivalent amount of sense, or rather, lack of sense.”

“Ditto. Guess I’ll go take a shower. There doesn’t seem to be much left to do but wait, and I need one anyway.”

“Right. I’m going to get some cigarettes and go down to the lounge. I’ll make a radio connection to the inter-phone just in case someone tries to call. We can answer it just as easily from there.”

XV

Something was bothering Lambert, something nagging away at the back of his mind. It was some little thing to be sure, he didn’t know what, but it was somehow important. As he passed the biology lab on the way to the showers he remembered that the animals hadn’t been fed for almost three days. He opened the door.

Here. This was the place. It was something somebody had said. Ian? No. Wait a minute. Yes. Or was it…Bud? Yes, something Edwards had said. No. Still not right. Something both of them had said. Now, what could it be?

Lambert looked slowly around the room. He needed to see something that would jog his memory, something in the room. The rats? The hamsters? That was it. Over there, near the wall. His gaze locked on the object, and with a cold and growing horror, Lambert finally put it all together.

XVI

When Riley came into the lounge, Lambert was sitting at the conference table drinking coffee. He had a towel wrapped around his wrist.”

“Well, well, if it isn’t Ron Ely.”

Lambert looked up at her a little distantly. “Who?”

“Ron Elly. An Actor. He used to play Tarzan on an old television back in the early seventies or the late sixties. I forget which.”

“Oh, I see.”

Riley broke open a fresh carton of cigarettes, took out a pack and tore off the cellophane. She shook out a cigarette and lit it.

“Mind if I have one of those?”

“I didn’t know you smoked.”

“I don’t.” Lambert took the cigarette and lit it rather clumsily. He inhaled deeply and coughed.

“Don’t try to smoke it all at once. Take it a little at a time. If you’re not used to them they can be kind of rough.”

Lambert stared at her. He had regained his composure now, but it wasn’t easy to say. “I know what happened to the others.”

“What?”

“I said I know what happened to the others. I couldn’t figure it out at first, but I know now. I had to put something Jirasek said with something Edwards said. You were right, Bea. Oh my God, I’m so sorry, but you were right.”

“You’re not making any sense, Chris. What in the hell are you trying to tell me.”

“Here, do you know what this is? It’s the answer. It says it all.”

“Edwards’ butterfly collection? What’s that got to do with it?”

“Everything. Jirasek told us when he said ‘collection bottles’. You were right there, Bea, whatever’s out there isn’t a human, but it sure as hell acting like one. It’s collecting samples. Samples of human life… We’re the damn samples.”

“Oh, Jesus, Jesus, Jesus.”

“I think I’m right about something else too. I think we’ve been isolated. I think that it, or they, or whatever you want to call it, is just sitting out there, maybe playing some alien equivalent of solitaire, and waiting for us to open up. And when we do, we’ll both become prime specimens, pinned to some galactic butterfly board. Ornithoptera lunaris… or Ornitoptera humanis”

“What if we don’t open up? What if we just sit tight and wait for help to come? Sooner or later one of the other bases is bound to send someone to find out what went wrong over here. As soon as they can’t raise us by radio or land line or Internet they’ll come over here to find out what happened.”

“I think they probably already have sent someone. We’ve missed our 1200 radio check for three days. Whoever they sent wouldn’t know what he was walking into, probably couldn’t fight it even if they did. No. I don’t think we can count out any outside help. The only real question is whether the ‘collector’ will get tired of waiting and go away, or take out his can opener and come in after us.”

Riley sat there for a moment, digesting what Lambert had said. She wasn’t sure if she believed it. The answer was just too incredible. And then, as if suddenly accepting her fate, she said, “Well, shit. Just shit.”

Riley stood and opened her locker, searched and then took out a bottle of Cutty Sark scotch. She held up the bottle.

Lambert nodded and she filled two plastic glasses half full.

 “We’re not going to make it easy for it, or him, or them, are we?”

“No.”

“So, I guess we better find some way to pass the time.” Riley tossed her head, shaking her long red hair and running a hand up one it to lift it from the nape of her neck. She swallowed her scotch and looked at Lambert.

“Do you want to continue with whatever experiments we can?”

“I don’t think so,” she said, refilling the glasses. “The main antenna is melted anyway. If I’m going to be a prize specimen, I want to be sure I’m going to be well preserved in alcohol. I’m going to get drunk.”

Lambert looked at her perspiration-grimed, beautiful face. He lifted his glass asking for a refill.

“To butterflies,” he said. “No. To drunken butterflies.”

(A final note: For those who believe this is somewhat derivative of Alien, I’ll point out that the story was written in the mid-1970s, three or four years before Alien was released. For those who wonder how I can prove it, I say because it was part of that short story collection that Bob and I had written. I have the letters to our agent and the rejections from the publishers. I have the table of contents that lists the story among those we had written… and this was originally written on an old manual typewriter. Try typing on one of those for several hours. Not a major physical feat but certainly more difficult that using a computer key board.

And yes, I can see a couple of plot holes, based on the increased technology of today, but some of that didn’t exist when the story was written. I mean, they should have known that the tower was destroyed… shouldn’t they have had video monitoring? We could create a problem with that as well. Some sort of computer glitch that didn’t tell them what the problem was and they couldn’t see it because, given they were on the moon, there would be no reason for video monitoring. Wouldn’t have to worry about vandalism or other such nonsense.

Anyway, the story would make a good movie, I think. We’d need a little more blood and gore at some point, and throw in a sex scene showing, at least, some of the interaction among the crew.

There isn’t much else to say about the story. It is what it is. A short story that takes place on the moon in the future… and given the attitudes of the 1970s, it wasn’t out of the realm of possibility that we’d have bases on the moon by today. Makes you wonder what happened to suck the sense of adventure out of all of us.)